If you’re ever been on an interview, you’ve most likely heard any of these useless questions:
- Where do you see yourself in 5 years?
- What are your greatest strengths?
- What are your biggest weaknesses?
- Why do you want this job?
- Why should we hire you?
- What type of animal/tree/food/mineral/planet are you?
Now I’ve seen many interviewers that say these are very important because they say something about the candidate! Yes, they say just how much time you’ve wasted online looking for answers to these very questions. Overall, they say nothing, and really have nothing to do with any job.
After all…
#1 Where do you see yourself in 5 years — what are you psychic? Now the interviewers say they want to know what goals you have for yourself to see if their inline with the company… but in all honesty, chances are in 5 years you’ll be looking for another job because either they’ve let you go, the company’s shut down, or just the job totally sucks and you’re needing something better, or they aren’t paying you enough. At the same time, there’s not really that many companies that have advancement no matter what job you’ve got. You a programmer? Great! Start at an entry-level position, work your way up to senior programmer (maybe 10 years if that), but after that you’ve got to either leave the company or enter a position unrelated to programming. If they’re looking for a programmer, and you say in 5 years you’ll be doing something other than programming (because, well, you might just be if you advance like planned) – do you really think they’ll hire you for a programming position?
As a similar thing, how do you even know that during the interview some plane, semi, train, car, etc isn’t going to come crashing through the building and take you out – or just cause the business to close shop? How do you know you won’t die unexpectedly while sitting there? You have no clue what will actually happen 5 seconds from now, let alone 5 years. A similar thing exists for what you’d be expecting: you can’t give specifics, only some vague standard “doing a job related to {the job I’m interviewing for now} with a company I love” which is pretty much the happy little lie that the interviewer likes to hear even though they know you’re lying. You’d really like to see yourself owning your own island with tons of parties, money, and not having to work.
#1.5 What guarantee can you make that you’ll still be here in 5 years? — This is a question sometimes asked, but is really similar to #1, so we call it 1.5. A person can’t guarantee that they’ll be alive in 24 hours — there’s no way they can guarantee you’ll still be working for them in 5 years. The business can’t even guarantee that they’ll be around in 5 years. They can’t even guarantee that they’d still be keeping you around that long. This question is the dumbest one around as you can’t even give a standard response – as it requires knowledge of the future, and a guarantee that knowledge of future events won’t cause the future events to be changed (so everything’s set in stone, if you know you’re going to be killed in a car accident at 8am, even if you have yourself committed into a padded room, the act of you getting committed will cause you to die in the accident). Yet there are some really dumb people demanding a guarantee from people before they’ll hire them.
#2 & #3 What are your greatest strengths/What are your biggest weaknesses? — Yeah, and who’s going to say their biggest strength is the ability to drink anyone under the table, and the biggest weakness is missing too much work from being in jail for drug offenses? Once again, the interviewer expects you to lie and give a canned response. But if you think about it, do they really want your strength/weakness in reality, or as related to the job you’re applying? If it’s in life, it doesn’t apply and shouldn’t be asked for it has nothing to do with the job at hand; if it’s the job, what if you’re just now entering the field? Do they want you to answer given your jobs overall? What if you got injured at your prior job in a way that you couldn’t/shouldn’t do it anymore, and are going into a different field? The greatest strength of a human resource manager wouldn’t really matter if you’re going to work in a non-HR capacity. If your job was as a programmer, your greatest strength/weakness wouldn’t apply to a non-programming job — overall of course, as some things (ability to solve problems, etc) could overlap in a general sense.
#4 & #5 Why do you want this job / Why should we hire you? — For virtually everyone in the world, the “why” would be “I need a job/I need more money” or a variant thereof, and the answer of why they should hire you, if answered honestly, would be the same answer. There’s not much else to say about this, every so often a person wants a job because they actually just want the job (and don’t need a new one, they’re moving on because of desire), every so often a person has a unique set of skills that matches a job position perfectly. In the end, why the company should hire you over someone else is entirely up to the company. A person either has the requirements for a job, or they don’t. They’ve got no idea what skill set anyone else applying for the job has. It’s just one of those questions that is pretty much useless. The person needs a job – that’s it. If they applied, they aren’t overqualified for the job. They aren’t going to leave you in a few weeks for another job (generally). They applied and showed up because they need a job.
#6 What type of animal/tree/food/mineral/planet are you? — Or any other question along these lines where they try to figure out what makes you tick by saying you’re a “yellow fox orbiting Jupiter”. The interviewer might have some psychology-based research paper that says “someone who identifies as a ____ is ____” and might be going by that to find the “perfect match”. Yet the person applying for the job might say they’re a cat because they like cats, not because they’re a predator that stalks and kills their prey.
In the end it all comes down to a few things about job openings, a business will always end up getting more applications than they have open positions. Some people will have to be cut. But questions like these and others that are just dumb to even ask could all be eliminated with one very simple way: have the employee wait 5-10 minutes in the waiting room, and ask the receptionist their opinion of them, and what they did (or use security footage). That’s it. If they practically bite the head off the receptionist, you’ve got a better idea of what type of person they are than what type of animal they are. If they’re polite, look around, check out any awards, pictures, etc you’ve got up about your business – you know they’re interested in your company. If they sit like a dead log and don’t even check out the rules of the business that might be on the wall, you can figure out other things.



